Collateral Protection Insurance Comparison: Traditional vs. Monthly Payment3 min read

Scale with Question Marks
(Last Updated On: June 17, 2019)

Collateral Protection Insurance (CPI) is a valuable tool for financial institutions, protecting them against loss of a borrower’s collateral.

“But Joe, the borrower has insurance for that situation. What’s CPI do, then?” Great question. While the loan terms require the borrower purchase and maintain physical damage insurance, do they always keep it?

When insurance coverage lapses…

Bandages Crossed

For a range of reasons, a vehicle sometimes loses individual insurance coverage. The borrower may fail to pay the premium, or simply allow it to lapse. That’s where Collateral Protection Insurance kicks in to protect the institution’s collateral.

CPI combines comprehensive “force-placed” coverage with state-of-the-art monitoring to track coverage and refunds. Traditionally, CPI was charged annually. This created an affordability and logistic challenge for refunds and such, so…

Monthly for Simplicity

Month Calendar

To simplify the program while making coverage more affordable to the borrower, some providers built a “Monthly Payment” form of CPI. It charges premiums by the month, reducing costs for borrowers possibly already financially strained.

Most CPI vendors now offer such an option. You can often find it with the branding “Hybrid CPI”.

This article discusses the differences between Traditional and Monthly Payment CPI programs. We hope to help you make the best decision for your borrowers and institution.

We’re happy to chat with you about CPI from our partner provider, Insurance Services, Inc. (ISI). Of course, their CPI solutions may or may not be a fit for your institution. Our information is useful regardless of which provider you may choose.

So, what are the differences? And which type is the best fit for your institution? Let’s take a look:

Monthly vs. Traditional CPI Comparison

CPI Type:Monthly PaymentTraditional
Is insurance tracked?Yes.Yes.
How is premium charged?Only exposed borrowers pay.Only exposed borrowers pay.
How is premium rate determined?Flat monthly rate determined through underwriting.The premium is CFPB compliant & based upon outstanding loan balance.
Who can file a claim?May be single or dual-interest. If dual-interest, both parties may file a claim.Typically dual-interest. Both parties may file.
What is the liability limit?$50,000.$75-100,000. Lesser of loan balance, ACV, contract balance, or limit of liability.
What is coverage term?Continuous until canceled. Individual certificates must be renewed at each term expiration.Continuous until canceled. Individual certificates are effective for 12 months.
Are there refunds?Yes. Monthly pro-rata.Yes. Daily pro-rata.
Is there premium deficiency coverage?No. If premium is added at the end of the loan, and institution is unable to collect premium, this will result in a charge-off.Optional lender coverage.
Is there Instrument Non-filing coverage?No.Optional lender coverage.
Is there conversion and confiscation coverage? AKA, “Skip” coverage?No.Optional lender coverage.
Is there repossessed collateral coverage?No.Optional lender coverage.
Is there mechanics lien coverage?Optional lender coverage.Optional lender coverage.
Is there repossession expense & storage coverage?Optional lender coverage.Optional lender coverage.
What is the notification process to the borrower?Series of monthly letters at the renewal of the monthly policy.Same, plus a series of compliance letters which run from 56-77 days.
What is the grace period?30 days. (New loans)30 days. (All exposures)
What is the standard borrower deductible?$500.$500.
What is the standard lender deductible?$500.$500.
Which program is less costly to the borrower?Flat rates, no integrated lender commission, borrower perception, and other economies, generally make monthly less costly. In truth, costs are dependent upon the actual portfolio and borrower behavior.Full annual premium is added, giving a perception that it’s more expensive.
How long is the average in-force term?The smaller monthly premiums may not create as much urgency to secure coverage. According to one provider, borrowers keep Monthly CPI in force an average of 8 months.Traditional CPI stays in force on average only 4 months.

Summary

Any CPI program shares two basic goals:

  1. Protect the lender from the physical damage risk to the borrower’s collateral;
  2. Track and encourage borrowers to keep and maintain their own private insurance.

Whether you choose a Monthly Payment or Traditional CPI program, both can achieve these goals.

Is Monthly Payment CPI for your institution?

To clarify, the main differences with Monthly Payment CPI are:

  • Lack of some optional lender insurance coverages;
  • A flat fee as opposed to the traditional outstanding loan balance rates;
  • Refunds are monthly pro rata;
  • Terms are from 1-6 months;
  • Standard liability limits are typically lower.

However, its simplicity for all parties, combined with a “low noise level”, and low day-to-day cost help it achieve the main goal:

Provide needed insurance coverage without contributing to increased repossessions.

Such a program may outweigh potential shortcomings compared to Traditional CPI. Or it may not. It’s all about finding the proper balance for your institution.

The Right CPI for You

Business People Joining Hands Over Desk
Tacky, sure, but it is about trust and working together!

These are decisions best discussed with a trusted provider. Working closely to best understand the needs of your institution, they can help you make the right choice for all parties.

Then, you can spend more time focusing on your members, knowing your portfolio is protected 24/7, 365.

Want a hand to hold as you begin looking deeper at your CPI offering? Let’s start the conversation. We will stick with you no matter where it leads.